Hi London-
Do you send out a form with all the volunteer jobs at the beginning of the year? Check out our file exchange for these types of forms:
PTO Today File Exchange
If you lump all the opportunities together on a form, and let people know that there is going to be a lottery if you get more volunteers than you need, then it manages expectations and no one feels shut out. Hopefully, people will check more than one box, so you can make sure you get to let everyone volunteer for something.
BTW, we have the same thing happen with photo day at my kids' school and the PTO said that if there was a lottery, the same person couldn't win 2 years in a row : )
~Lisa
Get the latest expert tips, free tools and special giveaways delivered right to your inbox: